Gunners: Not Clever Enough & Not Big Enough

A posting after the Bolton debacle on the onlinegooner forum worthy of a bigger audience



Gunners: Not Clever Enough & Not Big Enough

Gilberto: Not the physical player we need in the centre


I'm breaking with tradition. In 23 years following Arsenal, whatever the loss, despite the scale of the setback I never publicly criticise Arsenal. Despite how hurt I feel inside, I'm too proud to do it. But enough is enough. Before I make my point, let me just quantify my stance. I'm not saying 'Sack Wenger'. I still believe he's the man for the job and that we have a lot to be positive about.

But I can't help thinking that Arsene's stubborness is delaying how quickly we'll get back to winning silverware. His 'total football' philosophy, his 'technical game', has gone too far. We didn't lose against Bolton because of Mike Dean, or because we were unlucky, or because Anelka had a blinder. Ok all three contributed to the scoreline, but we lost because we're too lightweight, not built for a fight and simply not clever enough!!

Pires is an Arsenal great but was a complete lightweight, for that also read Overmars. Neither would have scrapped out a result for you, but they didn't have to. They had a Vieira, an Edu, a Petit, a Parlour, a Keown, a Lauren - even a Cole dare I say it - to do that job for them. The Pires's, Henrys, Overmars's and Bergkamps waited until the 'physical' players had 'won the right to play' and then went on to to win the game for us.

Who in today’s teams does that for us? Toure on his own isn't enough. Gilberto isn't that type of player, not criticising him, but that's not his game, he isn't a Vieira or Edu. I've read today that we'll be fine once our midfielders physically develop. Ok granted, Cesc will gradually get bigger, but he isn't going to haul us back into a game through the weight of his tackling. And please don't try and tell me that Hleb, Rosicky, Walcott, Flamini and Van Persie are ever going to win us games through physical might.

I am not criticising these players, I rate them all, it's not a case of ability, it's a case of balance in the team. Their workrate can't be questioned but without players made of sterner stuff alongside them, to protect them and keep them in games, in this league over 38 games against the type of opposition we face, we don't stand a chance of winning the title. I remember the 97/98 double campaign after the 3-1 home reverse to Blackburn and again 01/02 following the same score v Newcastle at Highbury. We were way off the pace both years and things looked bleak. But when you looked at the squad, when we hit form you could see we had the players to grind our way back into things. I can't say the same of today’s squad. You look at the fixture list ahead, the places we have to go, and irrespective of the form we're in, I can't see us getting the consistent results we need.

I can't help feeling that Arsene has become obsessed with beautiful football. I'm not saying we should revert to long ball negative football or anything close to it. We played great football in 2002 and 2004, but we also had steel. We don't today and that is costing us big time. The younger players will eventually gain the necessary level of experience, but the squad we currently have will never have the necessary physical presence to sustain a successful title challenge.

Sorry to go on but the Bolton match was hard to swallow as I feel it's a situation which Arsene has created for himself. Feel free to shoot me down in flames - life would be dull if we all had the same opinion!


NEW! Subscribe to our weekly Gooner Fanzine newsletter for all the latest news, views, and videos from the intelligent voice of Arsenal supporters since 1987.

Please note that we will not share your email address with any 3rd parties.


Article Rating

Leave a comment

Sign-in with your Online Gooner forum login to add your comment. If you do not have a login register here.