Random thoughts from the Barnet Hills

ANLKB (Arsène No Longer Knows Best)



Random thoughts from the Barnet Hills

Arsene: Flogging a dead horse?


One of the saddest moments in George Orwell's famous book, "Animal Farm", is when Boxer, the horse that was an allegory for Stalin's stakhanovite loyal labourers, was put out to pasture and sent to the glue factory. Boxer was once a mighty worker on the farm but in his latter years, try as he might, was no longer the force of his youth. Sunday, was perhaps the moment when our own version of Boxer, Arsène Wenger, for so long a great servant of this club, saw his time coming to an end.

Wenger has always maintained that he would remain at the club as long as the fans wanted him, and that he wouldn't outstay his welcome. I, for as long as I can recall, have been in the "Arsène knows best" camp. Today I switch my allegiances - the tipping point was bringing on an unmotivated Arshavin to replace the splendid Chamberlain. However, it was the first-half performance, where we were totally dominated by an average Man Utd side, that left me feeling that we can no longer compete at the top with current management in charge. Djourou, who was awful in the first half, was exposed as a non-right-back time and time again. This is Wenger's fault, for, just as last summer when he reacted too late to make signings, we have been waiting four weeks for a left-back to be signed. The manager is no longer pro-active in the transfer market. Such carelessness is now a liability.

Yes, we have had injuries, but so have Utd amongst others. But this should not absolve the manager for putting out a team at home that did not turn up in the first half. Experiments have failed, such as Walcott, who yesterday looked far from a footballer. Time and time again, his decisions were awful. Whether we achieve fourth place or not, the time is now for a change. This change should not be just at the manager level, but among the senior coaching staff, medical team and the board, who have sat in their comfort zone for the past three years, when our regression has been masked by appearances in the Champions League.

The Online Ed made an apt point at the last podcast, where he stated that Spurs, with a smaller stadium and tighter budget, can compete with the best, yet we no longer can. It is a depressing state of affairs when your nearest rivals go to the Etihad and are in a whisker of being real title-contenders.

Who would join Arsenal as the manager? I would be in favour of Steve Bould being promoted to assistant, with Pep Guardiola coming in to replace Wenger. Now before I get slated in the talkback below, should Barça lose out to Madrid in La Liga, the Barcelona manager, who is a big fan of English football and only signs one-year rolling contracts at the Catalan club, may feel the time is right for a move abroad. Or maybe even Capello, Hitzfeld or van Gaal? Perhaps wait until Euro 2012 is over to see who may be available? Put short, there are plenty of capable managers out there who could steady the AFC ship back in the right direction. Failing that, take a punt on Bergkamp, who is doing his coaching badges in Holland. Just please change something in the summer.

Let’s look at the positives: we have a 60,000-seat stadium, a healthy balance sheet and promising youngsters coming through our system. This is Arsenal Football Club, bigger than any manager or player, and when we do (no longer ‘if’ in my view) appoint a new boss, the foundations are truly there to build a new era. Perhaps the likes of Usmanov, Dein and Bould can step up and see through a new pair of eyes how this great club can go forward, but one thing is for certain: the Wenger Way is coming to an end.

Finally, next weekend sees the visit of a resurgent Villa in the FA Cup. Another loss wouldn't bear thinking and could bring the curtains down on Wenger's tenure sooner than we thought...


NEW! Subscribe to our weekly Gooner Fanzine newsletter for all the latest news, views, and videos from the intelligent voice of Arsenal supporters since 1987.

Please note that we will not share your email address with any 3rd parties.


Article Rating

Leave a comment

Sign-in with your Online Gooner forum login to add your comment. If you do not have a login register here.

36
comments

  1. Nick

    Jan 27, 2012, 13:34 #17795

    If as he has said time and again he loves this club than he should prove it by letting us go, and not take the club to the cleaners in the process, then we could appoint a new manager without affecting our transfer kitty Mandy, but if wenger did take the 15million payoff, wed still have 35mill left for transfers from the sale of cesc and nasri, and you dont always need a superstar to come in ,look what a job the likes of brendan rodgers has done at swansea with a fraction of the money available to wenger ok he hasnt won anything but maybe with our resources behind him he could, also someone like that has a good working knowledge of the lower leagues where perhaps we could pick up a few uncut diamonds the way george graham did and i dont think hed compromise our playing style, if wenger bothered to look, theres a few really good prospects in the championship now, and in the positions we need cover for ,a good promising young british manager would get my vote over a highly paid foreign mercenary

  2. mj

    Jan 26, 2012, 15:08 #17749

    problems have been there for several years starting with Fabianski who would not get into a division 3 squad let alone a premier league . Cahill ,Scott Parker ,Mata,Given could all have been signed and would have transformed the squad . Arshavin has not "put his shift in" for three seasons ,everyone apart from Wenger can see that . Benayoun ? what is the point of that ? Mertesaker - a giant but cant head the ball and is too slow ? We needed a full back when Clichy was sold because Gibbs like Daiby is always injured . Wenger lost the plot some time ago and most of us are fed up with his denial of defects in the squad . Change is needed , Thanks Arsene now go

  3. CanadaGooner

    Jan 26, 2012, 14:51 #17747

    ... and would those teams in europe fare so well in the prem? apply some commomsense man! we've already seen what porto's supposedly 'guru' manager's doing at chelsea (after they paid so much to bring him in). Even the great mourinho with millions spent, couldnt win the CL

  4. What was the point in leaving Highbury?

    Jan 26, 2012, 9:12 #17722

    Please remember that wenger has a huge budget compared to 95Percent of clubs in Europe. He is also one of the highest paid managers in world football. Yeah, who would want that job!!!!!

  5. R Meade

    Jan 26, 2012, 8:26 #17712

    H Chapman is the only manager I can think of considered a top manager before taking over us. GG Rioch and Wenger our last three managers were from the lower divisions or Japan are people scared they will look a little foolish if someone comes in and there not known and do a lot better then Wenger not hard really how many teams lose games 8 - 2? And lose every week? Thankfully we do still have RVP or relegation would be on the cards but if you have championship players what do you expect, not Wengers fault though nothing to do with him this great squad we have it's all down to the board!

  6. CanadaGooner

    Jan 25, 2012, 21:37 #17703

    what Liverpool are doing is exactly what a club needs to do if you're serious about winning trophies: spend money (albeit knowing sometimes it doesnt quite work out (Suarez, Carroll) immediately), be committed in each and every competition once you get to the quarter-final stage (what's the point playing a bunch of B-team players in the quarter or semi-finals, even if it's just the carling cup - if you've come so far, might as well clinch it!). If Liverpool get past Man City tonight, hats off to them. They may then go on to win the Carling Cup, and crappy as that is in exchange for 60million or so they spent this season, it's still something and they can then build on that next season as their players would now know what it takes to go all the way (something critically lacking at arsenal)

  7. Westie

    Jan 25, 2012, 21:16 #17702

    No offence, but if you think Wenger is the Boxer character from Animal Farm then you have misunderstood the book massively. Wenger is Napolean all day long. At the club it's his way or no way, he is more equal than others......Read ithe book again.....

  8. Jimmy

    Jan 25, 2012, 21:06 #17700

    Good piece Pradeep. You always make a lot of sense. I'd love to see Pep at Arsenal, but sadly I think we might be a year too late because I'm not sure he'd come to a club noty in the Champions League which is a shame because for all the talk about he needs money, he's not afraid to deal with over-priced prima-donnas - Ibrahimovich was shown the door virtually as soon as he took over and Villa (who many in this country think is the bees-knees) was in and out of the team even before his unfortunate leg break, partly to accomodate Cesc. Sob!

  9. Chris Laing

    Jan 25, 2012, 20:52 #17699

    Pep Guardiola would never come, are you serious in suggesting Capello! You are clueless

  10. Ronster

    Jan 25, 2012, 20:25 #17698

    We almost certainly wouldn't be contemplating 'bunging' Wenger had Graham been remunerated as handsomely as the current incumbent.....nothing ''highly restrictive'' about Wenger's wage packet ay Mandy!

  11. clockendpaul

    Jan 25, 2012, 19:41 #17697

    Mandy..would dare not risk being part of this clubs financial model, do you mean the 140 million in wages financial model! I think most managers could use that. You do know don't you that there was a football club before your god arrived.

  12. Zbizz

    Jan 25, 2012, 19:32 #17696

    I can only afford to go to three/maybe four matches a season. When are the regulars going to start singing "sack the board"? Yes, we could get rid of Wenger - and the board are happy to leave him out to dry and i accept that he's made some braindead decisions, but does anyone thiink a new manager stands more of a change with the morons above the manager? Pressure the top - let's see how they like it because they are the one's turning our clubs priority money instead of football.

  13. Half Full

    Jan 25, 2012, 18:20 #17695

    It's a results business and there's no getting away from the fact that Arsene's results have been getting steadily worse. He does not appear capable of arresting the decline so to those who want him to stay I'd say that on the basis of the current trend the longer he stays the bigger the mess his successor will inherit.

  14. Mandy Dodd

    Jan 25, 2012, 18:01 #17694

    Ron, I was referring specifically to the managers n the head article and stand by what I have said. Pradeep, no , even with all you mention, the top and most ambitious managers will not necessecarily come here, for the reasons I have stated, ie cash to spend on players and wages, those top managers would not dare risk being part of this clubs financial model, which like it or not, the owner has embarked on. You may not like it but that is the truth. Tony Evans, yes sometimes you have to take risks to accumulate, but not stupid risks, witness the western economy and the current lack of accumulation going on. Liverpool have taken a few risks lately, they lie below us, and have around 75million worth of deadwood to shift, good luck to them. St arry allegedly took a risk as well, look where he has been in the last couple of days. Risks involving the running of a large football club need to be properly assessed and quantified or taken at the clubs peril, I do not see much assessment or quantification over the current hype and hysteria involving wenger, in fact , very far from it. If wenger was sacked, and a new manager and his staff appointed, that will come from....let me think about it.....the lions share of our transfer kitty, so the new manager is likely to have very little, if anything to spend. Jose, come right on over, the waters fine!

  15. mark from aylesbury

    Jan 25, 2012, 17:57 #17693

    Pradeep Im with you on your response, why do we fear who we could attract? financially we are in a very strong position I just don't understand those who assume that we will take on a 2nd rate managerial choice. A new broom could have tremendous results. Just a point though, if the new manager doesnt deliver will he be given 8 seasons to win a trophy? Think not somehow.

  16. Whinger_OUT_NOW

    Jan 25, 2012, 17:36 #17692

    Another AKB bites the dust. Good to see. Realists were clever enough to have seen this situation 3 years ago. Calling for Whinger's head then would have invited scores of AKB's to dump on the realists. Just amazes me as to how blind someone had to be not to see the the direction the football club under Whinger was taking..same defensive issues, same injury prone players, same buying of unheard of players. How could the AKB's not see all of this?

  17. Pradeep Kachhala

    Jan 25, 2012, 16:56 #17690

    Those who believe that an ambitious manager would not want to come to a club with 125 years of history, numerous silverware, a new stadium and very solid balance sheet should quite frankly be put in a room with padded walls. AFC is a great club, without doubt a potential new manager, especially a big name will want a significant budget, however I believe that this would be the kind of wake up call the Board would require. A new approach is needed and the issue is we see Sir Alex still knocking on but he is the exception rather than the norm, Lippi, Sacchi, Trapatonni, Capello and Cruyff all eventually could take their clubs no further and we have reached that point with Wenger.

  18. maguiresbridge gooner

    Jan 25, 2012, 16:54 #17689

    I am certainly not afraid of change and it's getting more and more like it's needed somebody is at fault and has to take the blame for the sorry decline in our great club whether it's arsene wenger or the board but i would certainly not want to see change just for the sake of it the person or person's coming in would have to be the right people whether it's from the dugout or right up to the board room personnal who are going to stop the decline and take this great club of ours back to where it belongs one thing is for certain the people in this position at the minute are doing themselves no favours.

  19. allybear

    Jan 25, 2012, 16:42 #17688

    Tony Evans its quite correct that in life you have to take risks&i dont think its a risk getting rid of Wenger. He has been in charge long enough&i cannot understand why people wont accept that he has to go at some stage so why not now before it gets worse?

  20. CanadaGooner

    Jan 25, 2012, 16:22 #17687

    Yes, we are indeed flogging a dead horse. That's the unfortunate truth. But another unfortunate truth is that we will get a donkey in his place

  21. Ron

    Jan 25, 2012, 15:27 #17682

    Mandy - You might have a point if what you mean by 'top Manager' is one of the elite list whos names get touted for any top vacancy. Wenger wasnt a top coach when he came. Nobody knew him. He became one pretty quickly! You're clearly of the view that there isnt one out there, no need to bother looking and never will be one out there so you keep what you have. Its a bit of a potty argument to be honest. Arsenal may not need one of the tried, tired, aged and tested clique. Gaurdiola was hardly box office when he got the Barca job was he and hes done OK. Its the boards job to get the right person to find the right person if they cant do it alone, pretty much how they get the top accountants to advise on how they can sustain their idle, fat arses loafing, smoking and boozing in that Diamond Club on our money, without spending f--- all on players. They manage that OK. Wake up.I apparecite that youre a Wenger apologist and ive no issue with that, but youre approach mirrors the Boards perhaps. Its an approach that befits a middle order, non ambitious Club which is where Wenger and this Board have taken us. If that was the intention, we may have well as stayed at Highbury! Youre not PHW are you?

  22. Theo Jensen

    Jan 25, 2012, 15:24 #17681

    Haven't had time to read all the comments so apologies if this is repeating someone else, but RVP's statement about there being no rift between Wenger and him seemed a little odd. He said 'the boss' knew the Ox had a calf strain but 'no one else [did]' (Alex included it seems...) but Wenger made no mention of that in the post-match interview. Seems like a retrospective fabrication to me and an exercise in PR. Even if financial constraints are the main source of our apparent decline Wenger tactically has been out of touch for a while now in my view.

  23. Red Member

    Jan 25, 2012, 15:23 #17680

    Mandy talks a lot of sense on here actually. Imagine Arsenal without Wenger and then think who the board might replace him with and what will happen after that. You might not think Wenger is too bad then.

  24. Martyn

    Jan 25, 2012, 14:40 #17675

    Forget Bergkamp, he won't fly. Pat Rice will move on at the end of the season so it is possible that Wenger will hang on with a reshuffled back room. Too little too late in my view but results in the next few weeks may see a complete change sooner rather than later especially if top four becomes totally unrealistic and Milan dump us out of CL. Anyway, cheer up, at least Wenger only has to face the verdict of the fans!

  25. Judge Fred

    Jan 25, 2012, 14:00 #17672

    Aside from all the major issues (you know them all too well) I find it totally unacceptable that AW spends an entire 90 minutes doing the following: berating the 4th official, standing there with arms outstretched questioning every throw-in going against us, picking on some poor defenceless water bottle. This would be laughable were it not so tragic. And dont get me started on his post-match interviews - his hasn't had anything of interest to say since 2005. These petty traits are not what Arsenal Football Club are about.

  26. bunch

    Jan 25, 2012, 13:57 #17671

    Good post. The Orwell referece is apt given the kind of doublespeak we get from the club's official organs.

  27. GoonerGoal!

    Jan 25, 2012, 13:45 #17670

    It,s so nice when somebody finally sees the light and echoes exactly what I have been saying in posts for months. More please....

  28. Tony Evans

    Jan 25, 2012, 13:45 #17669

    Please change the record Mandy. You have quite obviously run out of ways to defend Wenger and to keep resorting to saying his replacement is going to find life difficult, or that you don't trust the board to appoint the right man are not valid enough reasons to keep him. Who knows we get another golden era under someone new. Sometimes in life you have to take risks and for Arsenal this is that time.

  29. Ron

    Jan 25, 2012, 13:14 #17666

    Yes, i reckon the FAC game on Sunday could prove to be something of a watershed if we lose. The thing is, im on record as saying that we could yet win the FAC even with all the troubles. It just seems set up for it somehow unless AWs delusional preoccupation with the CL stops him setting up a team with the players and the will to try and beat Villa for starters of course, which could well happen as we all know. Whichever, watch him sacrifice RVP v Villa for starters.See you at Wembley maybe!

  30. What was the point in leaving Highbury?

    Jan 25, 2012, 12:25 #17659

    If wenger doesn't put a full team out against Villa on saturday then it's official - we are activily not trying to win anything afterall after a weeks rest why can't the players play another game?

  31. Mandy Dodd

    Jan 25, 2012, 11:24 #17650

    The top managers will not come here, as they will most probably flounder on our highly restrictive wage cap, they will not want to risk reputations. Guardiola is used to a team where he can go out and spend 60 - 70 m at least every summer, despite the club in apparent financial difficulties. He can pay what elite players demand, helped by very player friendly taxes. An Arsenal manager cannot do any of the above. Managing self sustainablity against doping, working for an absent owner , far from clear on his ambitions for the club, Why would these guys take the risk? If you want Wenger out, look at our board and financial restrictions and think very carefully on the calibre of realistic replacements

  32. Alister

    Jan 25, 2012, 11:06 #17647

    Villa at home in the FA Cup. A manager struggling to hang on to his job. Hmm. Sounds like 1983 and Terry Neill all over again.

  33. Gare Kekeke

    Jan 25, 2012, 10:57 #17646

    Great article. I concur with your choice for a potential managerial partnership post Wenger should change happen in the summer. Pep wants to manage in England and according to football writer close to him in Spain, he has a 'fascination' with our club. Spot on with Steve Bould too. It's important to retain an Arsenal identity on the coaching staff as Wenger did with Pat Rice. Agreed with too that change has to happen at boardroom level too. The board one day must realise that football clubs make money off the pitch by great things on it**** and I mean the odd trophy here and there and not 3rd & 4th finishes without the odd piece of silverware. Whatever happens to Wenger, EVERY Gooner worldwide MUST without a shadow of a doubt give Wenger credit for his overall outstanding contribution to the club.

  34. Nutty's Right Peg

    Jan 25, 2012, 10:54 #17645

    Good post, however even if we lose on Sunday,& at Bolton, &,dare I say it,at home to our nearest & dearest, I can still think of around 14 million reasons why the board won't give Wenger the old tin-tack.

  35. Joe Mitchell

    Jan 25, 2012, 10:50 #17644

    Agree with your comments on Wenger. I've been in the AKB camp for a while and like you i felt the Man U defeat was just 1 to many. Second half we looked good but lacked drive and when the Russian came on i was dissapointed. More at the support for the boo's that greated his arrival. Yes he needs to be sold asap but to react like that was not good. I'll be behind the team against Villa if we lose i may invade the pitch and drop kick Wenger all the way too PSG.

  36. aj

    Jan 25, 2012, 9:55 #17638

    High on emotion. Low on intelligence. Yes, things need to change but none of this holds together at all.