Alex James: A Fans Favourite

A piece in honour of a long time Gooner subscriber who is no longer with us.



Alex James: A Fans Favourite


We were sad to learn this week of the passing earlier this year of possibly our oldest subscriber, 96-year-old Jim Holdsworth.

His son Bob told us Jim had been going to Highbury since childhood and therefore saw the 30s side in which Alex James was his favourite player and remained so right up until a certain Dutchman joined. After a few seasons of Dennis, Jim had to admit that Bergkamp might just be the best he’d ever seen and he saw a few!

Bob told us how much Jim enjoyed The Gooner although always felt we should have more about Alex James. So, with Bob’s permission, as a tribute to Jim here’s a piece about Wee Alex which originally appeared in issue 210 as part of Brian Dawes’ excellent series which celebrated the 32 players who appear on the stadium cores.

Football immortals are a rare breed and unseen at Arsenal until Herbert Chapman's era. One such immortal was 'Wee' Alex James. Signed by Chapman in June 1929 he was unquestionably the greatest player to wear the famous red and white jersey up until the Wenger era. James was the megastar of his day and in the early 1930's probably received more media attention than any over footballer in Britain. Born at the turn of the Century and brought up in a tiny Scottish village James graduated from local football to play over 100 games for Raith Rovers before moving south of the boarder to second division Preston for a £3,000 fee. His move to Arsenal followed a falling out with the Preston manager who refused to release him for a Scottish international match. Now given that James was a proclaimed Scottish maestro and one of the 'Wee Blue Devils' who destroyed England 1-5 in April 1928 you can see he would have been a tad peeved.

Chapman signed James for £8,750, a massive fee in its day but just maybe the bargain of the century for the Gunners. Chapman visualised him in a creative role and moved James far deeper than the goal-scoring position he'd occupied for Preston. Once accustomed to his new deployment he became pivotal to Arsenal's domination of the decade. His then was a deep lying position from where he was able to spray passes to our flying wingers Bastin and Hume or thread tantalising through balls to the likes of Lambert up front. Such passes often resulting in breakaway goals and James's vision was key to our high goal tallies in his years with the Club. His full array of tricks were also something to behold, as indeed were his shorts.

Alex James trademark long baggy shorts were a result of a cartoon made of him whilst playing with Preston, a caricature that he decided to live up to, wearing them with pride and not a little flamboyance. A happy-go-lucky, self-confident humorist Alex was well aware that other professional sportsmen earned more than footballers and went on a one-man strike during the summer of 1931 demanding a pay increase. Thus becoming the only player to cause Chapman grief during his reign at Highbury. Our manager had even secured him a contract with Selfridges as part of the deal that brought him to London.

In 1930, during his first season with Arsenal, Alex scored the opening goal and set up the second in the FA Cup Final win against Huddersfield, our Club's first major trophy and also the first of Alex's two Cup winners medals. The following season he missed only two league fixtures in our first Championship winning season. In fact of the 200 league appearances Alex made between 1930 and May 1937 he was only on the losing side thirty-six times. His influence in Arsenal's four Championships wins was massive and there can be no doubting that he was the king-pin of the team. With Alex at the helm in midfield the Club scored copious goals whilst dominating the decade. Injuries however reduced his playing time until he retired aged 35 at the end of the 1935-6 season. Arsenal's place in football's meritocracy had by then been firmly established, thanks in no small measure to the great Alex James.

Please respect this piece by keeping the comments on topic


NEW! Subscribe to our weekly Gooner Fanzine newsletter for all the latest news, views, and videos from the intelligent voice of Arsenal supporters since 1987.

Please note that we will not share your email address with any 3rd parties.


Article Rating

Leave a comment

Sign-in with your Online Gooner forum login to add your comment. If you do not have a login register here.

34
comments

  1. Bob

    Aug 23, 2015, 21:53 #74499

    I never saw him play, but from everything I have read, learned and been told, he was the greatest footballer of all time.

  2. Finsbury Joe

    Aug 23, 2015, 0:17 #74484

    Wow, a fan who saw some interesting times. RIP Jim

  3. mbg

    Aug 22, 2015, 16:45 #74481

    Nicosia Gooner, I bet that post gave the wengerites indigestion just in around tea time, Chapman put Arsenal on the map? that will not have went down well at all, don't you know it was their messiah who did that, without him we'd be nothing, non existent he invented Arsenal he made us, I bet the majority of them don't even know who Chapman was, and you can be sure the AKB's think their lord and master is a tactical genius he certainly does himself. Yes Chapman will always rate above wenger along with George Graham and they'll both be remembered long after wengers not.

  4. Nicosia Gooner

    Aug 21, 2015, 18:15 #74464

    I'm not sure who would prevail in the Berkamp/Alex James contest - I guess the fact that James remains a legend 80 years on says a lot, although the Dutch master may well achieve the same. Chapman though to my mind will always rate above Wenger: first he put Arsenal on the map - prior to Chapman Arsenal were the WBA or Stoke of their day, although maybe that is being a little unkind to those clubs! But the other key point is that Chapman was a true tactical innovator, whose change to W M changed the world game. Even Wenger's greatest supporters would not point to his tactical genius. what would Chapman have achieved had he been given 20 years at the club rather than nine?

  5. Badarse

    Aug 21, 2015, 3:55 #74438

    Bob, and Mark from Aylesbury, you may both be familiar with W.H.Auden's poem, 'Funeral Blues', if not then take some time to read it. Simple, melancholic, but beautiful, it may speak to you of how you feel when you think of your Dads, it does me.

  6. Jason B

    Aug 20, 2015, 19:17 #74432

    Thank you for the memories,Jim.If it wasn't for the likes of you and your friends of the day keeping the faith football wouldn't exist.R.I.P my friend.

  7. jjetplane

    Aug 20, 2015, 12:59 #74422

    BOB know what you are saying re the Totts game . I can remember walking from Manor House with hundreds of gooners but can never remember how we got in but we did and my younger brother feinted and we were taken to a nice comfy spot and saw the goal perfectly on a side view. Maybe saw your Dad feeding the horses that night. What an incredible memory!

  8. Bob

    Aug 19, 2015, 22:16 #74411

    It's been great to read these and the kind comments about my Dad, Jim. Makes me realise how lucky I was to hear his stories of 90+ years supporting The Arsenal. We went to Highbury together for years but the story you've reminded my about took place at the Enemy. My Dad left work early to get to White Hart Lane for the final game of 70/71. The streets were pack and queues massive. Dad had always like to give the police horses a polo mint. He walked to the front of the queue went through the polo routine with the police and strangely found himself in line for the turnstiles. The rest is history.

  9. exiled&dangerous

    Aug 19, 2015, 20:35 #74409

    As someone has mentioned above, I also like to read articles like this and Robert Exley's. Was always fascinated by the stories I read of the '30s side when I was a kid, and I'm convinced that Real Madrid would not have had the first European dynasty if the European Cup been around a couple of decades earlier. Especially with Herbert Chapman's reputation for innovation at a time when our own FA were too pig-headed to bother with the World Cup. To add my own personal thoughts as others have done here - I was born relatively late in my father's life, as was he to my grandfather, and I find it strange to think that I'm just two generations removed from the trenches of WW1. I would have loved to have met and spoken to my granddad of his memories of life way back then. RIP Jim Holdsworth.

  10. Exeter Gunner

    Aug 19, 2015, 20:08 #74407

    Can remember my Granddad telling me that at Highbury in the '30s they'd let schoolkids in for free at half time. So he'd have seen Alex James in the flesh too. Amazing to think it's 80 years ago now. Precious few of Jim's generation left.

  11. mbg

    Aug 19, 2015, 19:48 #74406

    jw, your right, they probably have no interest at all (that's if their even aware of it) and neither I suspect does wenger himself as he's so busy and interested in trying to make his own history with not much success. That's why it's always good to have articles like this and Robert Exleys, and hear about supporters like Jim Holdsworth to keep us all reminded and in touch with our roots. I can just see the fans you've mention looking up and googling when arsene signed Alex James.

  12. Alsace Lorraine de Totteridge

    Aug 19, 2015, 16:20 #74405

    If you want to see Alex James in the flesh as it were you have only to search out "The Arsenal Stadium Mystery" or, somewhat more obscurely, "Arsenal" part of the "Britain in the 30's" series on the BBC in the very early 80's. There is also some interesting material in Tom Watt's book, "The End". This was an exceptional time in the life of the nation, as the modernity which took hold after the technical innvoation forced by World War 1 took hold. Arsenal were the Manchester City / Chelsea of their day with lots of money spent to move the club to North London ( prior to world war 1) and then on players under Herbert Chapman. At the centre of midfield was the wee scottish genius. The comparisons with Bergkamp are appropriate with the ball being placed exactly where it needed to go. Although Arsenal were called lucky and were doubtless envied for money thrown into transfer fees, the team was built of defensive stability from which an attack could quickly spring. Chapman was succeded by George Allison and Tom Whittaker. Only the Second World War was able to halt the dominance of a team full of stars but organised and operated by professionals who combined innovation with adherence to strong principles of the game. The Club generated huge enthusiasm all over the world.

  13. Badarse

    Aug 19, 2015, 16:14 #74404

    That was a sweet comment Mark from Aylesbury, thank you. A bit maudlin I guess, but I lost my Dad over thirty years ago and I still miss him like it was yesterday. He wasn't a footie fan, yet clearly respected this odd young son who went to bed in an Arsenal shirt, and a cowboy hat-have stopped wearing the shirt recently as it's a passion killer-the hat still works wonders though. It is a double-edged thing, if you love someone so deeply that a little of you dies with them it wounds so deeply, but how lucky to experience such sweet pain. I wouldn't change a thing.

  14. Man United Killer

    Aug 19, 2015, 15:59 #74403

    Will all Gooners please Stand Up! RIP Jim!

  15. Peter Wain

    Aug 19, 2015, 15:57 #74402

    My farther always said that Alex James was the finest footballer Arsenal ever had and the best he had ever seen. He watched football all his life and saw Best at his peak but he always maintained that wee Alec was the better player.

  16. Mark from Aylesbury

    Aug 19, 2015, 15:16 #74401

    badarse- a little off the subject and I say this in all respect to the request keep on topic. You do get a bit of a hard time from me and others. I do believe your longer prose is suited to an article . You have been around for sometime watching the Arsenal . Perhaps think of writing up a piece comparing now and then. Anyway I leave it to you but would like to add your comments were really warming, the overall contributions to this RiP article have really got me thinking about how Arsenal is s myth . Myths are not lies though and it is that wonderful sepia tinged grand vision of Arsenal that has taken many of us on s life time journey.

  17. Tony Evans

    Aug 19, 2015, 14:20 #74400

    Hi Ron - Wolves would always be in the top division for me, along with many other fallen giants - apart from Leeds that is! Re Pompey my dad was always fond of reminding me that they had held the cup the longest - having won it in 1939! Also agree re the ridiculous Liverpool love in that still persists in the media: when do we hear any stats mentioned about their 25 years since a title win? Our 11 years, of course, is mentioned with boring regularity. Best player for me - incredibly difficult and I can't split Henry and DB10. We should have won more with those two in the team, backed up by the best defence we have ever had; the reason we didn't I suppose is a mixture of Wenger not getting the most out of them and the fact that Ferguson was also presiding over a pretty special team and he squeezed every last drop of talent out of his side.

  18. Ron

    Aug 19, 2015, 14:10 #74399

    Hi Jeff - Liverpool were more or less non entities pre 1960. Majestic record for the following 30 years to 1990 though. Post 1990 of course is Rafas CL that looked every bit to me to have been fixed and bought that night. Milan might have well have stayed in the dressing room such was its blatancy. The 'Gerrard final' my a--e. More like the 'we were ordered to stop playing' final! Agree re AFCs euro record. For a Club of its size, especially in comparison to the other London Clubs, none of which have been or even now in my view could ever be considered 'big Clubs', their record is lamentable and punctuated by melt downs. They've never desired any genuine euro pedigree though really. Wenger winning a CL at Arsenal is a pipe dream. His only real chance came in 2004 but in fairness to Wenger i don't really think even with the unbeaten team, that we had the players at that time capable of winning the CL. Reality was that the mainstays of that team were fine players for PL glory but just slightly over the hill for CL pursuit. The same players 2 years or so earlier, under a different Coach might have bagged it for the Club though. We ll never know. Youre right though. As the primary London Club historically, never winning it is a great big chasm on the Clubs chronology.

  19. jeff wright

    Aug 19, 2015, 13:40 #74398

    I guess you are right that players positions must be taken account of in the greatest of Ron but if given just one choice of a player then I go for the Dutch master. It's a strange thing though this history of clubs and how it is perceived Ron . The Shanks and Paisley 'boot-room' time of dominance domestically and success in Europe defines Liverpool's claims . They as you say have not looked like world beaters since even though winning the European Cup with rotating Rafa. United's history is based on the Busby and Ferguson periods Best forget about the inbetweeners ! Relegation and all. We have perhaps been the more consistent domestically over the years although you have to go back to the Chapman era for any back to back title wins and domestic dominance. Wenger has despite all the ballyhoo about him never managed to do that trick. Like ourselves there are big gaps of mediocrity involved with those two clubs but it's difficult to argue against us and the other two having been the biggest clubs in terms of titles won over the 100 years. That pesky European Cup that Wenger claimed he would win is a however a glaring omission on our club CV and a sad illustration of Wenger's 20 years of failure to achieve his ambition - that some other manager's have done in a very short time span with their clubs. Wenger would not have got 20 years at Real Madrid that is for sure,and that's why when given the chance to join them he declined it and stayed in the comfort zone with us. You couldn't make it up.

  20. Bob Matthews

    Aug 19, 2015, 13:12 #74397

    Similar story,as a child in the sixties and coming from a family evenly split between the Arsenal and our local rivals it was my father whose tales about the likes of James, boy Bastin,Hapgood etc inspired me to fall into the red side of north London. He did a great job because back then our neighbours were at there very loudest and a temptation for an impressionable young lad.Thanks to him i made the right and proper choice, god bless him. He died eight years ago and was just as fervent and passionate about our team the day he passed on.R.I.P Jim and if we do live on after death Bob, i hope he meets my old man .... they would have a lot to discuss.

  21. Ron

    Aug 19, 2015, 13:12 #74396

    Jeff - Bergy gets the nod from me too as the 'best'(if thats ever possible to sensibly establish as distinct from players in other positions?) AFC player in my lifetime. By some distance. History of the game has been rendered irrelevant at most Clubs now hasnt it. I saw that Liv game the other night and it was quite funny though listening to the pundits and the commentator speaking though of Liverpool as a great all consuming, powerhouse of football etc instead of the quite beatable team by any Club thay play, that they clearly now are. 2 plus decades of failure there never erases history by the pilgrims at SKY tele does it!!

  22. jeff wright

    Aug 19, 2015, 13:02 #74395

    Sadly the supporters that have joined us since the Wenger era, or eras, (blimey it is going on forever !) commenced show little interest in our history prior to his arrival. Even GG's exploits have been airbrushed from history with everything being Arsene that counts. I go along with the sadly departed Jim's view on DB10 though as being the best that I have seen at AFC . I was not around in Alex James time but my dad was ,he died in his 90s 4 years ago, and he said that James was a great player in his day .My view is that great players would always be that in any time given the same fitness training and current medical regimes that the current ones enjoy. Having said that I do believe that Wenger, due to a combination of the long time that he has been with us and his well known stubbornness and myopic vision has allowed our fitness / training and medical ones to stagnate and become outdated.

  23. Ron

    Aug 19, 2015, 12:54 #74394

    Hi Tony - yes, as a very young kid i can recall the elder statesmen talking often of how great Pompey were at one time and Wolves too. Used to then look at the league table when i was say 10 to 12 yrs old and think, what? Cd conceieve of the Wolves as a true powerbase of British football at that age, yet they had been and as you ll know, they were the true pioneers of euro football as they played such euro titans of their day like Honved and Partisan Belgrade at the Molineux under the lights. Man U claim to be the pioneers but its a gross lie which unfortunately a high number of footie fans choose to believe.

  24. Tony Evans

    Aug 19, 2015, 12:41 #74392

    Ron - Arsenal was a massive presence on my mothers side of the family, with one uncle of mine in particular always remembering the good old days of the 30s. Made a huge impression on me as a young boy and definitely was the reason I ignored my fathers team, Portsmouth, in favour of The Arsenal. Alex James, Ted Drake, Cliff Bastin are names from a bygone era now but, as you say, they are very familiar to me, despite being born long after they had hung up their boots.

  25. mbg

    Aug 19, 2015, 12:29 #74391

    Away before my time and most on here I suspect, but great to hear the stories and history of such a great player. I do remember mulling about around the north bridge area waiting for he ground to open some years back 08/09 I think and this old gentleman came passing by with a couple of other lads with him, he was wearing one of the original bobble hats with a line of red around, it would have been white at one time but looked to have yellowed probably because of cigarette smoke in pubs over the years, I remember thinking wouldn't it be nice to have a couple of pints with him he must have seen a lot in his time. Now i'm not saying it was Jim but you never know.

  26. Ron

    Aug 19, 2015, 12:21 #74390

    Not sure its a unique fan thing re Arsenal but many of us had Dads and Uncles etc who were nippers who either grew up with of just after that 30s team and as a result we sort of felt as familiar with that team despite having been born 20 or 30 yrs later. Bard - very true what you say. My Dad said the same things. Now people are on tenterhooks whether to stay or go from the Old Triangle wondering if their hearts can withstand 90 mins of Merter and old 'turn yr back to ball' Kossie!! R I P Mr Holdsworth.

  27. Bard

    Aug 19, 2015, 11:48 #74389

    Great article. My old man was a massive gooner and he likewise thought Alex James was was the best he'd ever seen. He told me stories about how the fans would wait outside the ground waiting for the team news to make sure James was playing before they went in.

  28. Badarse

    Aug 19, 2015, 11:18 #74387

    As a nipper I had many heroes but they were all fictional. Superman, Flash Gordon, Hopalong Cassidy, Roy Rogers, and Alex James sort of squeezed his persona into that illustrious group. Real, but a little like a fictional hero to me, as he had already shuffled off. I 'traded' off his ability and exploits in discussions with other kids, a bit like holding an ace in my hand-that's what you do with heroes, isn't it? Thank you Brian for that article, it's prompted some nice thoughts. Poignancy from Bob but what good memories to hang onto; Jim was also a wise footballing man. Losing someone close can be a body blow, so too with our own Mark from Aylesbury. What a strange emotion that bitter-sweet feeling. If I were you Mark, I would hang that key ring in pride of place where all could see. Chin up. Good old Arsenal.

  29. Nick

    Aug 19, 2015, 10:16 #74386

    RIP Jim, my grandad, who brought me up and was the only father I ever had introduced me to the Arsenal and Highbury as a five year old in 1958,it was a short trip as we lived off of Blackstock road, my memories of that game have gone bar the wonder of the noise, the colours all around, the scarves , rosettes and a still green pitch, hard as I try the players and result are a blur beyond my ability to clarify, but it started my life long love for the club. My grandad would wax lyrical about the great thirties side and his favourite player Alex James, we would talk endlessly of the Arsenal my imagination being fired by his stories of the glory days that I had to wait many years to see a return of, sadly he passed away in 71 after suffering a heart attack a day after watching the Arsenal beat Portsmouth in a tight FA Cup replay at Highbury, ive always felt cheated of seeing his undoubted joy when we went on to win the double and end the barren years of domestic glory, butt his tales live with me still,my heartfelt sympathies to Jims family,they too can take solace in the memory of his stories of yesteryears mighty Arsenal, and as Jim and my Grandad would have said UP THE GUNNERS !

  30. Tony Evans

    Aug 19, 2015, 9:08 #74385

    Incredibly sad when someone with such a link to the past passes on. What amazing memories Jim must have had and I would have loved to have shared some of them with him.

  31. Westlower

    Aug 19, 2015, 9:00 #74384

    Growing up as a kid in the 50's I was lent a book on Arsenal FC by Brian Glanville. What an impression it made on me, it was like finding a religion I could believe in. So many heroes of which Alex James was probably the greatest. I could recite all of the teams of the 30's off the top of my head. Special heroes were Bastin, Hapgood, Hulme, Jack, Drake & Male but top of the pile was wee Alex James. My love for the provider in the team was born. Since James we've had numerous stars play what is now termed as the number 10 role. Logie, Bloomfield, Eastham, Graham, Sammels, Ball, Brady, Davis, Rocastle, Bergkamp & now Ozil. Alex James was the first and probably the best ever in that vital role as link man between defence & attack. Jim Holdsworth must have had many happy memories watching the dominant team of the 30's. Well played Jim. R.I.P.

  32. Charlie George Orwell

    Aug 19, 2015, 8:06 #74383

    RIP Mr. H.

  33. Mark from Aylesbury

    Aug 19, 2015, 7:35 #74382

    Recently I lost my father an Arsenal supporter who was there from commencement of football after the 2nd world war. When cleaning out the belongings from his flat, a horrible task I found a key ring with 10 Berkhamp on it. It brought a smile at time of great sadness and I hope this article does the same for Bob. A fitting tribute to an Arsenal supporter through and through

  34. Th14afc

    Aug 18, 2015, 21:55 #74377

    RIP Jim