Arsenal should play the Bielsa Way

An open letter to Arsène Wenger to try a 3-3-3-1 formation



Arsenal should play the Bielsa Way

Marcelo Bielsa – Tactician admired by Cruyff


Dear Mr Wenger

I am a Season Ticket holder and lifelong fan for 40 years. I hope you read this and it won't take up too much of your time.

I would politely like to do something constructive instead of moaning and request a consideration on a change of tactics.

I have been studying formations and am an admirer of Cruyff and his tactics, and the Dutchman was in turn a big admirer of Marcelo Bielsa and his tactics. I have studied him and I believe the way we play and the ideology of you is suited to his fabled 3-3-3-1 formation.

As you will know Cruyff would prefer to only play three central defenders if he had the personnel to give him an extra man in other areas. I think this can work for us, with Kos, Mustafi and one other in the first phase of 3 with crucially Bellerin next to Xhaka in the next 3 with Elneny. This allows Bellerin to be involved in build up play but also allows for six defenders when we do not have the ball.

You can pick any number of players in the attacking 3 and can accommodate Jack if you bring him back. Ozil is pivotal behind Sanchez as the 1 but can play the false nine and has licence to roam.

For me, Xhaka is the vital component here in the no 4 position. He is the axis like Guardiola or Mr Vieira. In fact the purchase of Granit is why I think this can work. He is an excellent buy.

If Santi was available he would be a dream as is 2 footed and perfect for switch play. Xhaka has good vision to play ball between the lines.

This system must incorporate a high press and so players must be instilled with the desire to get the ball back very quickly. Bielsa's tactic is to have a lead man to press immediately and then have players near to play triangles. So, Sanchez can press and you must ask for more effort from the 3 behind. This frustrates the opposition and makes them go long.

It gives you your dynamic football that you desire. If executed correctly, you will have an extra man in every area of the pitch. I think this can work with also such an excellent mature keeper in Cech too.

This tactic will involve major effort as the team will play closely together and move together as an organism. We have young fit and very fast players so the time is now for this tactic in my humble opinion.

Mr Wenger, one other thing about this is that we will need to have better retention of the ball and so will need to train the players on the first touch as if the system breaks down we could be caught late on in a high tempo game.

I wish you a happy Christmas and good health. I would really like a personal response from you as I have thought long and hard about this and want only the best for us all in the Arsenal family.

Yours sincerely,

Cyril, Block 18, East Stand


NEW! Subscribe to our weekly Gooner Fanzine newsletter for all the latest news, views, and videos from the intelligent voice of Arsenal supporters since 1987.

Please note that we will not share your email address with any 3rd parties.


Article Rating

Leave a comment

Sign-in with your Online Gooner forum login to add your comment. If you do not have a login register here.

35
comments

  1. mbg

    Dec 10, 2016, 1:55 #95479

    I think the Bisley way would suit a lot of them a lot better.

  2. Cyril

    Dec 08, 2016, 22:02 #95445

    Luton: yes you are right it is very high pressure. That's the challenge as I am asking to see. In a really fit world, why can't we go for it. It's purely a proposition that's all.

  3. In The Luton End When Caesar Fell

    Dec 08, 2016, 12:51 #95423

    Bielsa's club projects have characteristically run out of steam by mid - March / early April in the first season, due to the insanely high energy levels required to maintain the effectiveness of his formation and tactics. Have a look at his time in Bilbao, two cup finals lost in one season because even the notoriously hardy Basque boys couldn't hack it, by the time May rolled around the squad was cream crackered. Bielsa's also fond of handing his cards in early if he doesn't get his way on everything, regardless of contract.

  4. Bonzo

    Dec 07, 2016, 13:12 #95389

    Jamee - turning to your wife for a minute how do you explain your Argentinian student Joaquin who you are giving the "cough cough" English lesson too. Does she still believe your story? Don't worry your secrets safe with us, unless she reads the Gooner of course.

  5. Mathew

    Dec 07, 2016, 11:26 #95379

    The amount of confidence these wins brings to the team is invaluable. Considering their places arent guaranteed in the team, players are getting their best out. Ox, Gibbs, Perez, Gabriel, Holding, Ospina, Giroud...all these benched players are proving their qualities, I am glad Wenger has a headache now.

  6. Paul Ward

    Dec 07, 2016, 10:31 #95378

    Delighted to say I was wrong last night, the manager picked the right team and we got the bit of luck we needed in Paris( Ludo not quite the pub team that some on here believed?).To get 14 points in CL group is good going and we deserve credit for that. Superb performance last night aswell, bettered only by the Chelsea win this term, the ruthlessness in front of goal that we so often lack was there in abundance.

  7. Nick

    Dec 07, 2016, 10:29 #95377

    Well to say I'm surprised that PSG failed to beat Ludogerets is an understatement! What a good performance from us in Switzerland too ! The only criticism I have is that every moment of danger we faced was caused by our OWN temporary lack of focus and bad decision making, the Swiss team didn't createn anything off their own bat ! This is often the case with us especially against lesser sides if we can cut that out of our game or at the least minimise it we could well be a force still I'm reserving judgement until we have seen off Stoke ,Everton and put on a good gutsy display against manures blue IF we get 7 points from those games or better still nine then I'd start to believe trouble is we've been here before with monotomous regularity the last decade so if I'm wary of hoping it's no wonder ! Already Wenger has said he will NOT be buying in January this is stupid in my view a top signing in the winter window could provide a buzz to the supporters and give a filip to the team and add more competion for places to just say NO I won't buy is complacent and indicative of the parsimony at the heart of Wengers management which is why I want him gone at seasons end regardless of its outcome !

  8. Bonzo

    Dec 07, 2016, 5:56 #95376

    Jamee - no, you're the one with an issue with your neighbour, no doubt you knocked on his door thinking you were going to have it out, realised you'd get a right tonking like Pete gives you and thought you'd better keep quiet and offer him a meal instead. You can't back track on what you said. Sheer terror caused you to act like a poodle. He must be a really nice chap to accept the roadkill you'll cook him at the Rust Bucket. I feel sorry for him. Ps. Remember to hide Leekey's Gimp mask.

  9. mbg

    Dec 07, 2016, 1:02 #95375

    jw, yes TOF the hypocrite, he never takes less to stay and expects a rise to do so. It's that time again so here we go again with his stay loyal comments, (with the £ $ euro signs in his eyes and lighting up his face) just another way (as usual) of covering his own arse to make himself look good and come out of it smelling of roses among his worshipers, and no doubt they'll be fooled yet again, (but not everyone) if players move to better themselves and win things, we'll hear comments like they jumped ship, they betrayed him, they let poor arsene down, LOL. You couldn't make it up. wenger out now.

  10. Cyril

    Dec 06, 2016, 23:12 #95374

    I sent an old fashioned letter to Mr Wenger. It's packaged up as an email. It's meant to be ' old school'. It's not about being smart just about whether you will sight this. The point for me is whether you connect. I had a vacuous response from someone saying it's noted. That's not enough, I want Wenger to rip my formation apart. Tell me why It doesn't wotk ? ...

  11. Smithy

    Dec 06, 2016, 22:41 #95373

    How the **** did we top the group???

  12. mbg

    Dec 06, 2016, 22:26 #95372

    ArseneKnewBest, yes mate cut the middle man out, but you see that would never do it would have to include/be with dear old weng the messiah or nobody. wenger out.

  13. GS

    Dec 06, 2016, 21:47 #95371

    Leaky , welcome back from under your stone, I knew my post would wake you up. Good result , more than happy to be proved wrong & happy we finished top of the group, point is no easy game in last 16 , let's hope the draw is kind. Now , have you got anything interesting to add , or just slate others and state the obvious . Don't forget we have reached last 16 loads of times, hopefully our luck will change , but your brain cells won't . Plonker, now go and finish the washing up.

  14. Leek fc

    Dec 06, 2016, 21:39 #95370

    Foolish comments from a foolish person eh GS......... "not sure why Wenger can nick top spot" egg on your face stupid????

  15. GS

    Dec 06, 2016, 19:39 #95369

    Should have rested Alexis tonight , dead rubber game , not sure why Wenger thinks can nick top spot. A few tough teams currently 2nd, so it matters not if you finish 1st/2nd. Arsenal played PSG twice this season and were unable to beat them , some would say PSG are a 2nd tier team, like us. ....

  16. mbg

    Dec 06, 2016, 18:31 #95368

    jj, yes indeed what goal and game was that again ?

  17. mbg

    Dec 06, 2016, 18:14 #95367

    He hasn't changed his fooking tie in years so he's hardly going to change his tactics, i use that term lightly.

  18. Paul Ward

    Dec 06, 2016, 18:07 #95366

    Interesting system Cyril, lack of width a potential weakness, aswell as speedy opposing wise men getting down our sides.Anyway, unlikely to happen under a manager who is hardly renowned for tactical innovation.On more pressing matters , let's hope we avoid injuries in this doomed attempt to secure top spot tonight, also if he was so keen to win the group why has he been playing our number two keeper all the way through the campaign?Have to say his decisions are getting stranger with every passing season.

  19. Alsace

    Dec 06, 2016, 17:53 #95365

    What a lovely article. If Cyril could explain the rule against perpetuities or the "crossing the T" manoeuvre at Jutland and Tshushima, or a little light brain surgery to the team and get them to understand it, then I'm sure we could be ok. Here however are some essential problems. (1) Our coach has only recently managed to understand the need for defensive midfielders. (2) Warfare is about arms races and all tactics have times when they create an advantage and times when they become old hat. (3) You need a system that you can do in your sleep, or under pressure. Lee Dixon will tell you all about it. (4) we need our defenders to commit to the defence and our attackers to the attack. The midfield have the energy to reinforce both and that is their job. 4-4-2 is readily and easily understood. If you divide responsibility you weaken your team. ( 5) In England Keep it simple.

  20. jeff wright

    Dec 06, 2016, 17:38 #95364

    Wengo's ( yawn) comments that Glum and Glummer should show loyalty to the club( he means himself) instead of demanding more money to stay, he did that himself before signing his 8.5m a year current contract , is surely a case of do as I say and not as I do if ever there was one.This clown's lack of self awareness and hypocrisy is breath taking.So we can safely assume that if someone waves more dosh at Glum he is not going to worry about loyalty to AFC. Deja vu Glummer who is working like a trojan to put himself in the shop window like RVP 'give him the ball and he will score' did in his last season with us . However, look where he has ended up after one successful season that he failed to replicate at OT in the next one .The criteria for success is higher there than in Wengo( yawn) comfy zone land. Had the gunner for life Dutchman stayed with Wengo ( yawn) he would still be trotting out with our side,ask Wally about it. Wally got his big bucks off Wengo(yawn) for showing sycophantic loyalty to Wengo(yawn) no one else in their right mind would have payed him 140k a week and tbh I can't see Ozil getting Pogbo United type wages,but it is a crazy mad money world footballers live in so who knows. One thing is for sure if Ozil does get an offer that he can't refuse he will be off faster than you can say RVP .I live in hope that Wengo( yawn) will wake up one morning to find a severed horse's head in bed next to him. His wife gave up her place there years ago so at least he will have some company. Of course as Ron suggested big buck offers for Glum and Glummer may well be what Stan wants anyway and Wengo's ( yawn) comments are designed to pave the way to allow them to be made with the excuses already in place for that happening. You couldn't make it up.

  21. bba

    Dec 06, 2016, 17:33 #95363

    Arsenal should play the Wenger Way. End of.

  22. mbg

    Dec 06, 2016, 17:06 #95362

    TOF says wally has great focus capacity, (whatever the fook that means is anybody's guess) most likely talking about a Ford Focus plenty of room inside. wenger out tonight.

  23. Roy

    Dec 06, 2016, 15:12 #95361

    Like your style, Cyril. Unfortunately you need an innovative manager, which ours no longer is. Best wait for the next one.

  24. mbg

    Dec 06, 2016, 14:29 #95360

    Cyril, the chances of him even knowing about the letter let alone read it are nil, and by some off chance he did come across it there's more chance of him winning his Holy Grail than there is of him listening to you, because you should know by now TOF takes advice from know one, listens to know one, especially fans, every chance he gets to stick two fingers up at them/us he does, the transfer windows over the last ten years alone should tell you and show you that, look at the team he'll put out tonight, and there's a couple more important things in this you seem to be forgetting maybe intentionally, we have an old past it manager who is certainly no Cruyff (and never was)incapable of playing like that and wouldn't know how, and of course you need the players also, we have a bunch of wallys, carthorses, injury prone nice boys who wouldn't/don't know their arse from their elbow, and would probably blow a gasket out of said arse when faced with that. wenger out.

  25. Mad Monk

    Dec 06, 2016, 14:08 #95359

    Been saying this is the way we should play for about 9 years and I am always incensed when he insists on playing people not equipped to fill in at full back ie Ramsey Chambers Flamini Djourou etc all too slow and in the case of Chambers away at Swansea a couple of season's past it was disgraceful of Wenger to leave him that exposed. I can remember the season we had every full back injured and he still insisted on playing a flat back 4 with central defender's, who weren't even good one's being played as full back's and then moaning that team's were unfairly targeting them ( Fulham away ring's a bell) Wenger will not adapt we definitely have the player's for this system and might actually beat a top side with it but it will only happen with a young hungry dynamic person in charge

  26. jjetplane

    Dec 06, 2016, 14:04 #95358

    Is it really true Jack is playing a less reckless game now he is with a coach who actually coaches. Stay where you are Jack or just keep away from the coach who is really just an accountant. Just heard Wengo talking about Sanchez and sounding most insecure. Advice to Sanchez - Go! Ozil like Wally will stick around forever in the comfort zone.

  27. jeff wright

    Dec 06, 2016, 13:57 #95357

    Arrogant know it all Wengo doesn't do taking advice from anyone.He is not above nicking others ideas regarding training fitness ones and such though and then claiming them for his own - if they work. Unfortunately the ones he nicked years ago have become,just like himself, outdated and dinosauric . As others have said this change to a technical formation against tippy tappy pass the parcel football that only works against lower case sides is way above Wengo's (yawn) rather big head and would interfere with his set substitutions and make deadbeats, such as Ozil,the most over rated player in the history of football , redundant with players of greater energy and endeavour being required to make the new system work. Wengo( yawn) will, to paraphrase some of the lyrics of the song on the Titanic movie sound track just go on and on with the same result that befell the doomed ship when the skipper ignored warnings of icebergs ahead ..whoops!...aaaaaaaggggggghhhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  28. Arseneknewbest

    Dec 06, 2016, 13:16 #95356

    Why not cut out the middle man and get Bielsa installed instead? As I said recently, a really deep thinker who's done it with low budget clubs and the big boys. He'd be a good fit - I know Diego Simeone also has advocates (and he is an entirely different kettle of pescado but nonetheless a credible contender). And as the photo shows, Bielsa seems not to favour zipped garments. What's not to like? Cyril - I always enjoy reading about formations and what they might do for a team's fortunes, not least because they add to my knowledge. Ron's vies are always worth reading too. If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, wengo should evidently look at what others do, and much as it pains me to say it, and not withstanding certain caveats, Chelski appear to have hit a winning defensive formula since they lost to us. But asking the atrophied chihuahua to do anything new is like, well, trying to teach new tricks to an old dog. He isn't going to give a flying toss.

  29. jjetplane

    Dec 06, 2016, 13:10 #95355

    There is just one post-tactic at Asano and that is if the oppo are pure let Sanchez beat them on his own and when the oppo is good let Sanchez run around like a headless chicken. Even Perry Groves did that better! Ozil pay packet should be downgraded and the difference given to Asano employees who are under the minimum wage. Ozil has few bargaining chips but he did score that goal. Do you remember .... the game was almost over and then Mesut (aaaaah) ......

  30. Bard

    Dec 06, 2016, 13:05 #95354

    Good article Cyril although as others have mentioned I dont think Weng has much interest in changing. My own view is that he doesnt do formations, he is more interested in a style of play, short passes and quick transitions. He favours small technically sound players over power and systems. Its largely why he comes unstuck against tactically astute managers.

  31. GS

    Dec 06, 2016, 12:56 #95353

    Good effort Cyril, your passion for Arsenal is clear. As far as Wenger is concerned , he is likely to file your letter under "Bin" as I doubt he knows what your talking about, and probably never heard of M Bielsa or indeed what tactics or formations are, he just lets the players get on with it.

  32. Exeter Gunner

    Dec 06, 2016, 12:46 #95352

    The idea that Wenger, at this late stage, is going to be trying anything new is fanciful at best. You want changes in the way the team plays, best hope for a new manager. Wenger will carry on exactly as he is for however many months/years he's got left.

  33. JB

    Dec 06, 2016, 12:32 #95351

    Sincerely, Cyril Aged 6

  34. Ron

    Dec 06, 2016, 11:26 #95350

    Hi Cyril - you touched on this last week didn't you. Interesting. It reads persuasively. Its a system that calls for a lot of discipline though isnt it, plus an understanding by players of other players roles. Maybe this is why its not seen in English football? As Redshirts says, im not sure we have the personnel to do it for the reasons he states and moreover i think Wengers far too long in the tooth now to adopt such deep rooted change and his back room staff are unlikely to have the tactical nous it calls for. Its too defensive anyway and wouldn't fit the 'philosophy'! PS just made the point on the other post that i wouldn't pay Ozil either.

  35. Redshirtswhitesleeves

    Dec 06, 2016, 11:05 #95349

    Cyril don't hold your breath waiting for a response, I doubt you've worked half a day in football after all! Very interesting points mate but regardless of formation you need players made of the 'right stuff' not a bunch of prima donnas more interested in beard grooming and hair gel than rolling their sleeves up when the going gets tough. Which is why I would pay Sanchez whatever he wants to stay and why Ozil can take a running jump if 200 odd grand a week isn't enough for him to turn up when he fancies it and go missing whenever we are up against it