The furore and excitement about the recent transfer window got me thinking about how this compared with past windows. Below I have listed the arrivals in the last 10 years’ worth of summer and January transfer windows. The information was gleaned from transfermarket.com. Those I view as top additions to the team are in bold and capitals. Giroud and Nasri are probably the only contentious ones but you may have different views. I have deliberately left out this season’s transfer windows as the jury is still out on whether they are any good.
2008/9
SAMIR NASRI
AARON RAMSEY
Andrey Arshavin
Mikael Silvestre
Amaury Bischoff
2009/10
Thomas Vermaelen
Sol Campbell (free transfer)
2010/11
LAURENT KOSCIELNY
Sebastien Squillaci
Wellington Silva
Marouane Chamakh
Ryo Miyaichi
Vito Mannone
Jens Lehmann (free)
2011/12
Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain
Gervinho
Mikel Arteta
PER MERTESACKER
Andre Santos
Ju-Yeong Park
Carl Jenkinson
Joel Campbell
Yossi Benayoun (loan)
2012/13
SANTI CAZORLA
Lukas Podolski
OLIVIER GIROUD
NACHO MONREAL
2013/14
MESUT OZIL
Emiliiano Viviano
Kim Kallstrom (loan)
Semi Ajayi
Mathieu Flamini (free)
Yaya Sanogo (free)
2014/15
ALEXIS SANCHEZ
Calum Chambers
Danny Welbeck
Gabriel Paulista
Mathieu Debuchy
David Ospina
Krystian Bielik
2015/16
PETR CECH
Mohammed Elneny
2016/2017
Granit Xhaka
Shkodran Mustafi
Lucas Perez
Takuma Asano
Rob Holding
Cohen Bramall
In my view there are only 10 that he has recruited in the last 10 years that could remotely be regarded as top class, in terms of their contribution over a period of time to the club. The two other players I would put in the same bracket are Wilshere and Bellerin, who came though the Arsenal system. So Arsene has effectively managed to bring in one top player for every two transfer windows. It is difficult to say definitively how good or bad that is unless you look at how other clubs in the top six have done but my feeling is it’s pretty poor.
Two things stand out from the list. We have invested heavily in mediocre to rubbish players. This doesn’t come as a surprise. But given the fact that many of us remember the recruitment of the likes of Henry, Anelka, Gilberto to name but a few, it’s clear that the level of players we have recruited over the last 10 years has gone down not up. The second thing that struck me when I looked at the youth players who were given full professional contracts on transfermarket.com – check yourself to see all the names - was the attrition rate among the young guns. Young players who flickered brightly for a moment and then disappeared. Only three have made it into the team in 10 years, Wilshere, Iwobi and Bellerin. In practice this means the much-lauded Arsenal youth set up manages to produce one regular first team player every three years.
To my mind this tells us two things about the club. Despite Wenger’s boast about bringing young players through in actual fact we are poor at youth player development. Secondly our scouting network is poor. Arsenal are the 6th richest club in the world, it beggars belief that a club of this stature can only find and recruit one top player every two transfer windows.
Many of us bemoan our defensive frailties, tactical naivety, mental attitude, substitutions and the like but the bottom line is you can’t win anything unless you recruit and develop really good players and since leaving Highbury in 2006 we haven’t done that. Hopefully the latest window signals a change of direction.