BEST XI ARSENAL

Review of the e-book by Damian Hall, Luke Nicoli, Andrew Mangan and Kevin Whitcher



BEST XI ARSENAL


Right then: so like me you got a Kindle for Christmas and now you're looking for books to download. Well one particular recommendation I can make is the 'Best XI Arsenal' now available from Kindle at a mere £3.04.

The essence as you might suspect is in the title and it's a game we've all played in pubs or on long away trips. Four fans arguing about their favourite players in each position, discussing the formation to be played and debating as to whether you can you pick players who played before your time. The difference between the pub/car journey game you've played and this volume is that each of the eleven players chosen here is honoured with their own chapter and each is written by one of four fine authors. Namely: Luke Nicoli and Damian Hall (both Arsenal supporting journalists), Kevin Whitcher (editor of The Gooner) and Andrew Mangan (known universally as Arseblogger). Each player's chapter is preceded by a list of their honours, why he's in the team, a quote and their greatest moment. But for me the main pleasure of this book is that each chapter is a beautifully crafted piece written with both care and passion by people who really understand.

Their chosen best ever XI provides us with a total of 4 Englishmen, 3 Frenchmen, 2 Scots, a Dutchman and an Irishman. So almost immediately you've worked out who the Dutchman is because as it says in the text 'If you have a player nicknamed ‘God’, you pick him'. For the Irishman you might possibly be speculating about a certain classic keeper or maybe the only player to have represented our Club over 700 times and whom is currently on the tip of your tongue. But it's more probable you picked a genius with a left peg to die for, someone who at one time might even have answered to the name of Chippy. Of the English players picked, one had a ponytail, one is now quite statuesque and two of them came as a pair and played in the Battle of Highbury. One of the Scots was famous for both his skill and his shorts, the other for his inspirational captaincy and the best night ever witnessed at Highbury. As it happens I'd let one of the Englishmen and one of the Scots fight it out for captaincy as I certainly wouldn't want to tell either that they were not being given the armband.

So which three Frenchmen were chosen? Well the greatest ever Premiership striker who also happens to strike a fine pose in front of Tiny Totts is a no brainer I'd have thought. A midfield powerhouse would also get pretty well everyone's vote and someone skilful and dreamy to make up the numbers would do it.

Unusually for most all time Arsenal XI's this one nominates three players from the fabulous 30's. Quite justifiably so given how massively important this era was to the Club. So now you know who they all are. Or if you haven't quite worked it out you might require an Arsenal history lesson. But let's assume you've figured the specific contents, what you'll want to know now is whether you should read them. Well my answer would be a resounding yes because each chapter is beautifully crafted by quality Arsenal supporting writers for the worthy Arsenal supporting fan I presume you to be.

I have to agree that this particular best Arsenal eleven would certainly be a bit special even though they wouldn't all be in my chosen team. But then again I doubt if more than one in a hundred Gooners will ever agree on a best ever XI. What they will agree about should they read this title however is that it's a very fine read for Gooners everywhere.

Competition

To win one of five free copies of the book on kindle, we are holding a competition. To enter, answer the following question…

How many league titles did Arsenal win while Herbert Chapman was their manager?

Entries by email, by midnight on Sunday (22nd January) to [email protected]. We will announce the winners at the bottom of Monday’s online editorial following the Man Utd game. Good luck


NEW! Subscribe to our weekly Gooner Fanzine newsletter for all the latest news, views, and videos from the intelligent voice of Arsenal supporters since 1987.

Please note that we will not share your email address with any 3rd parties.


Article Rating

Leave a comment

Sign-in with your Online Gooner forum login to add your comment. If you do not have a login register here.

21
comments

  1. GaryFootscrayAustralia

    Jan 24, 2012, 2:30 #17565

    aws and John A, my dad also picks Jack Kelsey every time these lists are done....and that's coming from a guy who just might be the most massive Bob Wilson fan of all time, so Kelsey must have been something special....

  2. SIMON TAYLOR

    Jan 24, 2012, 1:12 #17564

    1, JENNINGS THE BEST KEEPER I`VE SEEN 2, SAGNA 3, WINTERBURN 4, FABREGAS 5, VERMAELEN 6, ADAMS 7,BRADY 8,PARLOUR 9,HENRY 10, BERGKAMP 11,THIS IS TRICKY PIRES OVERMARS OR ARMSTRONG . THE IDEA IS THIS IS A TRULY WORKING TEAM , SO PARLOUR BECAUSE OF HIS WORK ETHIC WOULD CONDENSE THE MIDFIELD TO HELP BRADY AND FABREGAS THE SAME MIGHT BE SAID FOR ARMSTRONG PIRES 2003/4 ONWARDS GOT THIS WHEN HE FIRST ARRIVED HE WAS AS BAD AS ARSHAVIN AT TRACKING BACK . I ALSO TRIED TO GIVE THE TEAM BALANCE WITH TWO LEFT FOOTERS TOMMY AND LIAM . HOPE YOU LIKE.

  3. aws

    Jan 23, 2012, 15:48 #17526

    What is truly depressing is that if anybody chose the best 10 arsenal XI's of all time of the present squad only RVP would figure in the selections. Have to agree with John Abrehart - Jack Kelsey, for me, is the best ever Arsenal goalkeeper - it's a pity he seems to have been forgotten but in the 1958 world cup ( yes, Wales were in it) he was voted the Goalkeeper of the tournament.

  4. olly rafferty

    Jan 23, 2012, 15:39 #17525

    seaman, sansom,dixon,adams,oleary vieira, cesc,pires,bergkamp, henry,drake

  5. Peter Wain

    Jan 23, 2012, 15:18 #17522

    Best Arsenal Eleven Wilson McNab McLintock Adams Hapgood Brady James Bergkamp Veira Pires Henry

  6. Radfordkennedy

    Jan 23, 2012, 9:44 #17444

    1/Seaman 2/Dixon 3/Sansom 4/Storey 5/Mclintock 6/Adams 7/Brady 8/Vieira 9/Radford 10/Wright 11/Armstrong I know there are some big names missing especially upfront but ive picked a team that in my opinion would not be flat track bullies,would not go missing in cup finals,and would have a blend of skill and bottle....remember those days,the only regret is that i couldnt find room for 1 of the 3 degrees...my God!what a difference Rocky(God rest him),Sir Michael Thomas or Paul Davis would make to our team now!

  7. paddy luke

    Jan 23, 2012, 8:17 #17438

    wow- after recent times any of the names mentioned would be a god send. what has happened to my arsenal and why are these kind of names distant memories?

  8. GaryFootscrayAustralia

    Jan 23, 2012, 8:07 #17437

    Bartram - Vivas, Cygan, Pates, Traore - Malz, Hillier, Powling, Mendez - Diawara, Kiwomya. I tried to pick a team of duffers that none of you lot had already selected - yes, I do think Hillier was a duffer...would probably captain this team though....

  9. demar rankin-woodhouse

    Jan 22, 2012, 21:48 #17433

    Jennings,a.Cole, t.adams, t.vermaelen, Lauren, viera, pires, fabregas, FREDDIE L!!!, Dennis the menace, Henry

  10. Terry

    Jan 22, 2012, 12:49 #17428

    Best-Jennings Rice McLintock Adams Cole Brady Vieira Petit Pires Bergkamp and Henry Worse-Flappy Eboue Stephanovs Ceasar Silvestre McGoldrick Denilson Jenson Helder Chapman and Hawley.In my worse team i picked players who played more than a few games thats why no Hankin and Carter.Wost manager in my time Howe

  11. paddy luke

    Jan 22, 2012, 11:39 #17426

    Almunia, cole,stepanovs,ceasar,luzney,McGoldrick, lyderson, jensen, arshavin,chamach, bendtne. quality

  12. Davethegoonerman

    Jan 22, 2012, 11:02 #17425

    Jennings,Anderson,Adams,O'leary,Sansom.Viera,Petit,Brady,Pires,Bergcamp,Henry.Class!!!!!!!!!

  13. Gordon

    Jan 22, 2012, 10:26 #17421

    A Dutchman thats easy DB10 so is the 3 Frenchman PV4 RP7 TH14,the Irishman is Chippy.But two Scots?? Yes McLintock but who else?Alex James.Did any of the authors see him play of course not.Here's my 11 Jennings-Dixon McLintock Adams(capt)Cole-PV4 Cesc Brady-Bergkamp Henry Pires. My midfield and strikers all world class and a world class keeper.Cole is in my team because when he wore an Arsenal shirt he always gave 100% and during his time as a Arsenal player he was the best LB in the world

  14. James

    Jan 22, 2012, 9:38 #17420

    Jennings Dixon Adams Campbell Cole Vieira Petit Brady Pires Bergkamp and Henry.Petit because i would alway play him and Vieira together.

  15. Greg71

    Jan 21, 2012, 21:43 #17412

    Always a good conversation piece with plenty of views exchanged and different criteria such as periods in history,formation and could these players gel as a team. With all the different permutations suggested,would anybody like to challenge the important spine of any team and suggest an alternative to adams,vieira and henry and then build from there ? What about a worst 11,any contenders from the current squad ?

  16. JER

    Jan 21, 2012, 19:31 #17411

    Jennings - Storey, Adams, McClintock, Sansom - Pires, Vieira, Brady, Armstrong - Bergkamp, Henry. Restricted to players I've seen.

  17. Moscow Gooner

    Jan 21, 2012, 17:44 #17408

    There seems to be a good historical balance in this selection - which reflects well on the authors. Better than picking an 'all time' XI that doesn t go back for more than five or six seasons - as a lot of them (understandably I guess) seem to...

  18. John Abrehart

    Jan 21, 2012, 16:26 #17405

    I can only argue with two positions Tony, Jack Kelsey in goal and Sansom instead of Cole.

  19. kilkenny cat

    Jan 21, 2012, 16:20 #17404

    jennings,rice o'leary adams sansom, vieira brady pires. bergkamp wright henry

  20. andy boy

    Jan 21, 2012, 14:25 #17402

    COLE?!?!?!?!?!? Kenny or Nutty all day long! be serious mate its not april the first

  21. Tony

    Jan 21, 2012, 8:10 #17394

    Jennings-Dixon Adams McLintock Cole-Vieira Cesc Brady-Pires Henry Bergkamp.