Is Arsène Wenger still the best man for the job?

No-one could have done better than Le Prof



Is Arsène Wenger still the best man for the job?


(Ed’s note – This piece was submitted before the Dortmund game) At present, everything is rosy and the answer to the question is probably a little easier to reply to. Arsenal are currently sitting top of not only their domestic league, but of their Champions League Group as well and also came through a potentially tricky League Cup tie at West Brom - fielding some promising (and unproven) youngsters.

Let us cast our minds back to 1996. Were Arsenal a fashionable club? No. '94/'95 was an horrific season for us. You had the George Graham scandal, a poor league finish and then, of course, the loss of a Cup Winners Cup Final (and we all know how that ended!).

Bruce Rioch pulled back a little bit of our credibility with the signings of David Platt and Dennis Bergkamp and with qualifying for the UEFA Cup, but Arsenal weren't yet the global entity they are now. They weren't playing the glowing football that they are now renowned for having played in recent years and were struggling to fill a 38,000-seater stadium at times.

Enter Arsene Wenger. I always remember the 'Arsene Who?' headline that one of the major tabloid newspaper's ran, shortly after his appointment. He revolutionised the game almost immediately. He prolonged the careers of Seaman, Dixon, Winterburn, Bould, Adams and Keown and almost immediately the whole squad became athletes and were producing some of the best football of their careers, with his scientific approach. With the sprinkling of unknown gems such as Vieira, Petit and Anelka, Arsenal were well on their way to hitting the heights that is always expected of them.

The winning of the Doubles in '98, and '02, the FA Cup wins in '03 and '05 and, on top of this, the 'Invincible' season of '04 - great times for the club but it was the way we won these trophies that was most pleasing. Pires was an incredible buy and his telepathic understanding with Cole, Bergkamp and the phenomenal Henry, will be extremely tough to replicate, ever.

I think this now brings the subject on to the last eight years. Our own supporters are quite rightly not happy with the lack of silverware. Arsenal Football Club demands success and eight years without a trophy is not good enough. There have been near misses though. Fifteen minutes short of winning the Champions League in '06; the '07 League Cup Final; and the League should have been won in '08, in my opinion. The quality has always been there but, as if proving a habit, we always seem to fall at the final hurdle.

I believe Arsenal took a risk in moving to Ashburton Grove. Wenger had a vision and perhaps knew that, by moving, the success of the team might suffer for a number of years. Indeed, he may not have known to what extent, but then the board could have been more proactive. Since '06, Arsenal have had to balance the books. Cole, Campbell, Pires and Bergkamp left, Henry left, Clichy, Touré and Adebayor left, Fabregas and Nasri left and then, last year, van Persie left. All commanding reasonable transfer-fees and thus saving huge wages.

Wenger’s hands were tied during this time. He is the face of Arsenal and sometimes bore the brunt of the criticism. He went for the route of bringing youth through, but this doesn't cater for experience and know-how in the biggest games. We are starting to see fruit with the reinvention of Ramsey, while Wilshere will only get better. The signing of Őzil was a major signal that the times of watching the pennies is over, and the feel-good factor is back - you can sense it.

We are all fans of the club, we all love the club. Let's get behind the team and behind the Manager and with everyone pulling in the same direction, this could be our year. Wenger is the most successful manager is Arsenal's history, he has provided the club's greatest moments and unveiled some of our greatest players and, in my eyes, he is still the man for the job.

I hope you all agree.


NEW! Subscribe to our weekly Gooner Fanzine newsletter for all the latest news, views, and videos from the intelligent voice of Arsenal supporters since 1987.

Please note that we will not share your email address with any 3rd parties.


Article Rating

Leave a comment

Sign-in with your Online Gooner forum login to add your comment. If you do not have a login register here.

27
comments

  1. Izuchi

    Oct 28, 2013, 9:07 #40943

    Wenger is still the right man for the job And oh! Before you crucify him ask Moyes

  2. Danny

    Oct 27, 2013, 19:06 #40937

    Absolutely NOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  3. Finsbury Joe

    Oct 26, 2013, 21:03 #40911

    Unbelievable. Why does so much on here go back to Tottenham, is this not an arsenal site?

  4. Westlower

    Oct 26, 2013, 15:42 #40910

    Lies, Wenger has won 10.9% of the 64 trophys available to him in his Arsenal tenure. 3 PL & 4 FA Cup, 2 doubles + 16 years of CL. Currently on an unbeaten run of 14 away games + clear top of PL.

  5. Ron

    Oct 26, 2013, 12:06 #40909

    Finsbury Joe - Quite why you're here is a bit sad (most spuds are though i accept and understand why) but seeing as you are here, ill take up your point. You've just put up such an attractive proposition its a shame not too. Another 26 years of Arsene reigning at Arsenal? Hmmm I can see your argument. Lets consider it. If my maths are correct in that hes seen off 12 funny little spuds managers in 17 years, thats 0.70 muppet coaches at the swamp for each of his 17 years, in another 26 years, thats another 18 feckless muppets in the spud hot seat who'll all bite the dust while trying in vain to be Billy Nick. Sounds good enough for me. 30 spud muppet coaches all gone by the time Arsene s 90 can only mean your perennial failure to create some Club history is doomed. But then, we all and you too know that anyway don't we! Shut the door on your way out you funny little oaf.

  6. Lies, damn lies and statistics

    Oct 26, 2013, 11:54 #40908

    Westlower- Wenger has also won 0.0% of the 32 trophies available to him since 2005.

  7. Ron

    Oct 26, 2013, 11:49 #40907

    Westlower - Morning mate. They dare to finish below us every Season. They do lose most of the NLD s for years on end and never do have title tilts. They then dare to imagine they actually have a presence in North London and then do delude themselves that they do. They then dare us to pretend that they're a threat to our hegemony, when we know that they're not. I think they're a very daring and doing Club. 50 odd years of daring and doing cant be scoffed at.

  8. Westlower

    Oct 26, 2013, 11:01 #40906

    Finsbury Joe, To Dare is to Do. What is it exactly that Spurs dare to do??? CL remains but a dream for you Spuds!

  9. Finsbury Joe

    Oct 26, 2013, 10:56 #40905

    Despite letting themselves their fans their country league and Capitol City down in mid week I would quite happily see wenger at arsenal beyond his 90th birthday

  10. Westlower

    Oct 26, 2013, 8:10 #40903

    Whatever our individual opinions of Wenger are he has won 57.9% of his 968 games at Arsenal. No other Arsenal manager is close to this impressive win ratio. He has his strengths & weaknesses but he's in the hot seat until the end of the season so it's nonsensical to keep undermining him.

  11. maguiresbridge gooner

    Oct 25, 2013, 21:15 #40901

    TT, i can see your point about coming second with only a couple of points in it, or we're beat in a final, we were beat in a final years ago by mighty Birmingham, a greatly improved season? compared to the last five, six, or more yes. A reason for OGL to be offered a new contract and accept? nothing would have changed it would still be another year of failure and the buck stops with the manager, no body remembers losers.

  12. GoonerGoal!

    Oct 25, 2013, 20:53 #40900

    It's way too early to either ask or answer this particular question. The pressure created by our collective dissatisfaction finally brought about the Revolution that forced Wenger into denying one of his guiding "principles" with the signing of Ozil. The result being that we are well on target for 27 out of 30 Premiership points. Even if 24 of them were gained against 9 teams who failed to finish above 8th last season. So far so good then for the "new" Wenger. But, and it's a very large BUT, let's see what the end of November brings before even considering his future. VIVE LA REVOLUTION!

  13. jeff wright

    Oct 25, 2013, 17:14 #40899

    Spot on John, when Wenger had 5 world class players such as Vieira and Henry,etc, those players Wenger got away with just having plan-A and won trophies. Although there werte even with those players some blank seasons when Wenger should have won things. Wenger's current crop stick more rigidly to his master plan that he drills into them on the training ground than Vieira and Henry,etc, did . Wenger's substitutions are pre-planed regarding when they are made - and only injuries or dismissals changes this. Wenger even leaves players on who are clearly injured and struggling. At least things should go to plan against struggling Palace - to renew Wenger's optimism in his training ground coaching plans proving him right in the end. After 8 years of them failing though you need to be a super -optimist to believe that Wenger will turn-over the better sides and managers who have him well sussed out .

  14. maguiresbridge gooner

    Oct 25, 2013, 16:56 #40898

    Gavin no disrespect but we're all aware of what wenger who? brought to the club and the players he brought and the players whose careers he prolonged,and what he done for the club, the successes(whose to say another who or somebody else couldn't do the same) and it's all went down in history and i don't think anybody will forget, so we didn't need reminding but all that is in the past a long past a distant memory especially the successes.He was the right man for the job way back then.What he will be remembered for now is the last eight going on nine years of failure and the humiliations and all the rest that went with it regardless of the excuses that have been made for him and indeed still are. Is he the right man for the job now? the right man for the job is a manager who can bring success to a club and the team, and for the supporters a manager who can win cups, real silverware and honors. The current manager has had eight years to do that and failed, regardless of near misses no body remembers them. He has this season to prove he is the right man for the job and that means winning silverware any silverware, (because there's no more excuses left the well has run dry) but it will still not make up for the last eight years of failure it will take a few more to do that. And like the last eight seasons he doesn't manage to bring success this season when we have the best chance of doing so for years there's only one alternative and i think he knows that himself, well lets hope he does.

  15. John Gooner

    Oct 25, 2013, 16:44 #40897

    He can't do tactics, a fairly significant failing for a football manager. The main reason we have won nothing for 8 years is the fact that the manager cannot change the approach of the team to suit the opposition - Not a problem against the minnows of the PL and the lesser CL teams, but against the good teams, we get found out.

  16. Man United Killer

    Oct 25, 2013, 16:24 #40896

    Joker

  17. TT

    Oct 25, 2013, 14:11 #40895

    I'm not ashamed to admit I'm on the fence with Wenger. I still believe he is a great manager, coach and man but unsure he can deliver trophies. To be honest, that can only be proven at the end of the season but what if Arsenal finish second by a couple of points in the title race and get to the final and lose in the FA Cup? That would surely mean a greatly improved season, and despite not being able to win anything is that Wengers fault? He can only send the team out, if they dont play to their standard or perhaps are unlucky then thats not a reason for Wenger to be axed. If however its same old story it could very well be. I would act on caution though, I said a while ago the only manager I see as a future Arsenal manager was Roberto Martinez. His work with young players, his philosophy suits us but also perhaps Michael Laudrup does too? Its going to be a mammoth task of replacing Wenger no doubt about it so when the time comes the decision must not be rushed.

  18. Ron

    Oct 25, 2013, 13:49 #40894

    I dont normally have a dig at an original poster as its a laudable effort to do it, however this article deserves a place on Arsenal.com. not here. If you really think Arsenel 'werent fashionable' before 1996 than theres no hope for you fella. A token effort at checking the Clubs history was much needed before you splurged this puerile stuff surely?

  19. Johnny Lynch

    Oct 25, 2013, 13:01 #40892

    Seriously . You are ****ing deluded mate

  20. Mike

    Oct 25, 2013, 12:27 #40888

    Give him his new contract

  21. 600NER PETE

    Oct 25, 2013, 12:08 #40886

    In answer to the question...NO!

  22. jeff wright

    Oct 25, 2013, 10:13 #40883

    The fact that you are asking the question is Wenger the right man for the job suggests that it's debatable. The facts are that he was the right man at Highbury - where he had his glory days and that is not disputable. Whether or not someone else could have done better with using the resources available to Wenger since the move to the cash -cow Emirates is something that can't be proven or disproven. Leaving the qualification to the Champions League aside there are obvious flaws in Wenger's management during the Emirates period and with the 4th largest wage bill in the league he has not been pulling up any trees finishing 4th regularly as some claim. Wenger himself is stalling on signing a new contract - saying that he wants to assess his own and the players performances before committing himself . He blamed the players the other night for losing to Dortmund so it's unlikely that he will find anything to fault himself on if he does choose to say au revoir at the end of season. Personally I think he will go if he fails to qualify for the Champions League but will blame others for not being up to matching his genius. If he does qualify then it will be normal service resumed in Wenger's futile efforts to win a trophy that is beyond him ever winning. C'est la vie.

  23. silentstan

    Oct 25, 2013, 9:48 #40882

    give it a bloody rest

  24. Where's Wally is a Gooner

    Oct 25, 2013, 9:29 #40880

    Generally fans are happy if the team is moving forward.At best we have gone sideways for the last 4 or 5 years.This season looks like we may be starting to improve again but we haven't played too many difficult games yet.The next two months will tell if this club can compete against the best teams.If he does well then give Wenger another chance. If we continue to fail against the better teams then we need a younger more dynamic man in charge. Klopp obviously.

  25. lance peters

    Oct 25, 2013, 9:27 #40878

    at the end of this season we will know if he is still the right man. we had money to spend and he spent 42mil on 1 player. the squad is short of a striker. we know he tried for demba ba for why leave it for the last minute ??? we will get behind the arsenal for now but if we dont win any silverware this season then the 42mil will be money lost.

  26. Benny2

    Oct 25, 2013, 9:15 #40877

    No manager is perfect.

  27. CanadaGooner

    Oct 25, 2013, 9:14 #40876

    Simple Answer: Every job has performance criteria and in football it's winning trophies. The Dortmund result is besides the point. If we dont win a trophy at the end of this season, leaving Wenger in charge would be a joke. But as I always say; SEASON is in progress, so I am supporting the team and manager 100%